You have no items in your shopping cart.
Due to Hurricane Milton Payless Cigars & Pipes will be closed on Thursday, October 10th – All Orders will be shipped once we resume normal business operations.
Search
Filters
Filter by attributes
  • Country of Origin
  • Gauge
  • Length
  • Qty Per Unit
  • Shape
  • Strength
  • Unit Type
  • Wrapper
Cigars of the Year

Every year cigar journalists, experts, and enthusiasts gather to create their top cigars of the year list. Cigar publications like Cigar Aficionado, Cigar Dojo, Halfwheel, Cigar-Coop are among some of the most sought after lists year in and year out. Each has their own method of how they rank these cigars and what standards they must meet. Here at Payless Cigars and Pipes we are proud to offer a wide selection of Cigars of the Year, year in and year out! Check out the 2020 Cigars of the Year, the 2019 Cigars of the Year, and 2018 Cigars of the Year that we carry!

Q:          How do companies decide their cigar of the year?

A:           Some companies like Cigar Dojo only consider newly released, non-limited-edition cigars in their ranking. Meaning the Premium Cigars that they pick are truly what they deem to be the (New) Cigar of the Year.

Q:          Are the Cigars of the Year rare?

A:           Yes and no. While these cigars are usually not produced on a limited production basis, getting ranked in one of these esteemed lists greatly increases demand, making them harder to obtain! Payless is happy to offer Cigars of the Year from years past as well so you can make sure to try as many of these premium cigars as possible!

Q:          What is the Cigar of the Year?

A:           There are multiple cigars dubbed the Cigar of the Year each year by different companies! Check out our collection of the 2020 Cigars of the Year, 2019 Cigars of the Year, and 2018 Cigars of the Year!

View as
Sort by
Display per page
Montecristo Epic Vintage 12 Blue Toro

Montecristo Epic Vintage 12 Blue Toro

$171.10 $190.10
Montecristo Nicaragua Robusto Cigar

Montecristo Nicaragua Robusto

$273.80 $304.20
Muestra De Saka The Bewitched Box

Muestra De Saka The Bewitched

$127.93 $150.50
Muestra De Saka Unstolen Valor

Muestra De Saka Unstolen Valor

$127.93 $150.50
Sold Out
My Father La Gran Oferta Lancero Cigar

My Father La Gran Oferta Lancero

$194.99 $216.00
My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto Cigar

My Father La Gran Oferta Robusto

$154.99 $172.00
My Father La Gran Oferta Toro Cigar

My Father La Gran Oferta Toro

$164.99 $183.20
My Father La Gran Oferta Toro Gordo Cigar

My Father La Gran Oferta Toro Gordo

$174.99 $194.00
My Father La Gran Oferta Torpedo Cigar

My Father La Gran Oferta Torpedo

$172.99 $192.00
Sold Out
My Father La Opulencia Toro Cigar

My Father La Opulencia Toro

$223.19 $252.00
Sold Out
My Father Le Bijou 1922 Churchill Cigar

My Father Le Bijou 1922 Churchill

$273.99 $303.60
New World Dorado Robusto Cigar

New World Dorado Robusto

$103.49 $115.00
Oliva Serie V 135th Anniversary Edicion Limitada Perfecto Open Box
Oliva Serie V Churchill Extra Cigar

Oliva Serie V Churchill Extra

$273.99 $344.00
Oliva Serie V Lancero Cigar

Oliva Serie V Lancero

$295.99 $372.00
Oliva Serie V Melanio Churchill Cigar

Oliva Serie V Melanio Churchill

$141.99 $178.00
Olmec Maduro Toro Cigar

Olmec Maduro Toro

$160.92 $178.80
Sold Out
Oscar Valladares 10th Anniversary Toro Cigar

Oscar Valladares 10th Anniversary Toro

$172.80 $192.00
Padron 1926 No. 6 Natural 10-count box
Padron 1926 No. 6 Natural 10-count box
Padron 1926 No. 6 Natural (4-pack)
Padron 1964 Hermoso Cigar

Padron 1964 Hermoso

$413.40
Padron 1964 Hermoso 5-Pack
Padron 1964 Principe Cigar

Padron 1964 Principe

$330.00
Close
Filter by Clear All
Min: $53.00 Max: $464.00
$53 $464