In the growing portfolio of cigars from the artistically-minded Caldwell Cigar Company, the Blind Man's Bluff showcases a much different profile than its sibling brands. This is because Robert Caldwell—owner of Caldwell Cigar Co.—ventured away from his primary manufacturing partner in the Dominican Republic, instead partnering with the Diadema Cigars de Honduras, S.A. factory (aka the Camacho factory), located in Honduras.

Blind Man's Bluff boasts all A and B-Grade tobaccos, including an Ecuadorian Habano wrapper, Honduran Criollo binder, and Dominican (San Vicente) and Honduran (Criollo ligero) fillers. This combination manages to produce high levels of flavor with a surprisingly affordable price point. Blind Man's Bluff sets its sights at a medium overall body and loads of flavor, including characteristics of sweet roasted nuts, allspice, leather, and zesty nutmeg.